Historically, fire investigators have been individuals without any formal education or training in scientific methodology. One aspect of looking at radiant heat flux is to determine if the secondary object has been raised to a critical temperature or is receiving a critical heat flux where ignition of that object is possible. hb```f``g`a`` B@1V u_&I\P ePQQR("rlCl6JM "XyWrf0 & A seven step reasoning process for evaluating damage for determining the area of origin, along with a new definition for the term fire pattern is proposed. The cumulative heat exposure should be considered the leading factor in the creation of damage. The failure in knowledge transfer is most likely because experienced investigators, particularly those who obtained their basic training before 1992, were trained with misinformation and misconceptions (Lentini 2012). The authors would like to thank Bill Hicks for providing pictures taken during fire testing. The constant force is applied to the tool by two 3.3lb constant force springs. (1997)) and Gorbett et al. For example, one myth was that an investigator could determine the speed of the fire by looking at the width of the v-pattern. In the fire investigation profession, testing to determine whether the first burning object can ignite a secondary object is paramount to hypothesis testing of an area of origin. The fire was allowed to burn in post-flashover conditions for approximately 2min. Fire patterns identified on the floor have been a common theme within fire investigation as being a possible indicator that flammable or combustible liquids were used within the fire (Smith 1983; Beyler 2009). 2004). Mealy et al. 2003; Carman 2008; Carman 2010; Tinsley and Gorbett 2013) (Fig. National Fire Protection Association, Quincy (USA), NFPA (2014) NFPA 921-Guide for Fire and Explosion Investigations. 2013). Cambridge Press, Cambridge (UK), Morvan G, Jolly D, Dupont D, Kubiak P (2007) A Decision Support System for Forensic Entomology., Paper presented at EUROSIM 2007 conference, http://www.forenseek.org/spip/?A-Decision-Support-System-for,46, NFPA (1992) NFPA 921-Guide for Fire and Explosion Investigation. debris fall down). The other difficulty for forensic scientists investigating fires is that the observations of damage after the fire may often times be independent of the path taken by the fire making it difficult to identify where the fire started. The loss of mass from a material is typically dependent on the material and the exposure to heating. Many of the firefighting factors would not necessarily develop new patterns that have unique characteristics. Several studies concerning ventilation-controlled fires throughout the years have introduced a concept of a ventilation factor (\( {A}_v\sqrt{h_v} \)) and illustrated the importance of ventilation openings on a fires growth by analyzing the size of ventilation openings, locations of these openings within the compartment and the shear mixing that occurs at the interface of the opening (Kawagoe 1958; Thomas and Heslden 1972; Harmathy 1972; Thomas and Bennets 1999; Utiskul 2007; Sugawa et al. 1. This method or a similar method should be further explored using the work done for gypsum wallboard (Gorbett et al. During a fully involved compartment fire or when a compartment fire is ventilation-controlled, more complete combustion is achieved at those locations where the mixture is adequate. Therefore, the dynamic forces that drive flow through an opening are based on fluid dynamics and fluids in motion at the ventilation opening interface and the discharge characteristics of the opening. He found that the damage from the flame plume would extend approximately the width of the fuel for 100kW fires that did not have a ceiling jet form and 3 times the width of the fuel with 300kW fires that did have flame extension under the ceiling. 2003). The focus of this literature review is to identify the work that has been done specifically for forensic applications that have been conducted for identifying ways to observe and characterize varying degrees of fire damage through measurable or visible means. In March of 1997 four full-size compartment test fires were conducted in furnished bedrooms (Milke and Hill 1997). share common damage characteristics for the damage to transition from simply random areas of damage to being classified as a pattern requires that the damages are clustered near to each other and that the characteristics of the damage are similar. The production increases substantially as the compartment fire becomes ventilation-limited. This includes the spring housing and rear slider block. Correct determination of the origin depends on the correct. irradiances measured 0.05m away range to near 80kW/m2 for the fastest burning specimens; however, 40kW/m2 was not recorded farther than 0.44m away and 20kW/m2 was not found beyond 0.88m distant. Fire tests in a scaled compartment using a propane sand-burner were designed to rapidly progress through flashover with a short period of full room involvement. Photograph of a Plume-Generated Fire Pattern (fire origin was located at the base of this damage-test conducted at EKU by author). The damage observed to wall, ceiling and content surfaces is an artifact of the fire dynamics for that fire. The compartment can reach a state of full-room involvement without transitioning through flashover, or become ventilation-limited and never achieve full-room involvement state (Francis and Chen 2012). 1997). [1], This developmental curve reflects the progression of intuitive thinking processes as a person develops more advanced knowledge structures in a specific area. Fire and Arson Investigator Journal of the International Association of Arson Investigators 64(1):3747, Custer R, Wright C (1984) Open Windows and Thermal Inversions may Complicate a Fire Investigation. Illustrations from this first discussion are still found today in the current edition of NFPA 921 showing a cross-section of a floor with greater beveling or loss of mass indicating direction (NFPA 2014). These photographs and annotations are provided to illustrate the burn pattern indicated. Many of the studies discuss the production of unburned hydrocarbons (UHCs) during under-ventilated conditions that result in unburned fuel filling the compartment and undergoing combustion only where sufficient UHC concentrations encounter sufficient oxygen (Beyler 1986; Utiskul and Quintiere (2005); Utiskul 2007; Thomas and Bennets 1999). Not all compartment fires will transition through flashover (Drysdale 2011). The search for patterns starts at the very widest part of the V or U shape, the outside of the fire's burn path. (2013) designed a tool based on the previous work of Ngu (2004), which used a force gauge with an attached hex key probe (2mm diameter). Currently, investigators have no reliable method for identifying varying DOFD for charring. This production of incomplete combustion byproducts is exacerbated in poorly ventilated spaces, ventilation-controlled burning regimes and combustion of fuels that under normal atmospheric conditions have high soot yields (e.g. However, no specific details are provided on how to implement this analysis. Several correlations have been developed to assist in determining the minimum HRR necessary for flashover to occur, conditioned on the total surface area of the compartment (AT) and the ventilation factor \( {A}_v\sqrt{h_v} \) (McCaffrey and Quintiere (1977); Babrauskas 1980; McCaffrey et al. The science of interpreting burn patterns is considered important by fire investigators when establishing a fire'sarea of origin. The prescribed process by Mealy (2013) was time consuming due to the requirement on the user to be extremely careful in watching the gauge and then marking the probe with a piece of tape to document the depth, thus introducing potential error. Fire Research Station Note No. They focused on under-ventilated fires, the fire growth associated with these types of fires and their forensic analysis. However, if the mud and tape are not present and the compartment transitioned to a ventilation-controlled fire, the damage around these sources of ventilation may be significant (Claflin 2014; Mealy et al. Fire plume generated fire patterns are the most important to identify correctly. Finally, an area that is white in color surrounded by soot areas should not be classified as a clean burn area until closer examination is performed. 11). In this section of the literature review, sections 2.3.1.1-2.3.1.2 discuss the basic causes of fire patterns and will serve as the connection of fire investigation terminology to the fire science research that has been conducted in those areas. Direction of flow is typically associated with the lower line of demarcation being closer to the origin of the flow. The fundamental items within the definition that may assist in better defining the term fire pattern is that patterns are something that happens in regular and repeated ways with characteristic features. variables: the material itself, the RHR, fire suppression activities, temperature of the heat source, ventilation, and the length of time of exposure. The scene investigators most important hypothesis is the correct identification of the origin of the fire (NFPA 2014). The lack of damage has often times been overlooked in most discussions related to fire patterns. He then indicates that the contextual circumstances should also be evaluated, which include a relationship to other artifacts and associated casual factors (proximity to a fuel item), post-flashover conditions and proximity of damage to a ventilation opening. Safety, Security And Emergency Management | Safety, Security . Their method encouraged investigators to use fire patterns to arrive at an origin, but upon arriving at their hypothetical area(s) of origin required the investigator to provide some measure of accuracy in the form of a radius of error. The authors suggested that the investigator could evaluate the items involved and the differences of flammability of combustibles along the route of travel may explain the route of travel or spread (Straeter and Crawford 1955). They are examples only, not models. The skill can also be artistic such as painting or playing a musical instrument, and physical skills such a walking and weight lifting. Hicks et al. Around the late 1970s there was a movement within the profession to describe fire patterns by descriptions of their geometric shapes (e.g. The reported velocity of flows from wind-assisted or mechanically induced flows through the bottom of a door and window can be on the order of 10m/s (22 mph) (Kerber and Walton 2005; Madrzykowski and Kerber 2009). So you might have to check the size of the breakout candle on higher . U-shaped development, also known as U-shaped learning, is the typical pattern by which select physical, artistic, and cognitive skills are developed. As such, the recognition and identification of lines or areas of demarcation and the elevation changes with those lines of demarcation capture the essence of these shapes without using geometric shapes as universal descriptors. In addition, if these gases were undergoing flaming combustion as they exited the opening, thermal damage to the wall surface is expected to follow the same theory (DeHaan and Icove 2011). The evolution in terminology clarifies how fire patterns became a more restricted definition and it is this bounded term that will be the focus of this literature review section. The only method that appears to be systematized and examples provided was the truncated cone method in conjunction with the heat and flame vector analysis (Kennedy and Kennedy 1985). Wiley, California (USA), Kleindorfer P, Kunreuther H, Schoemaker P (1993) Decision Sciences: An Integrative Perspective. In these texts the authors stressed that the investigator should evaluate low burns for possible ignition sources, but did not necessarily link the damage to ignitable liquids. The rooms were instrumented with heat flux gauges, thermocouples and gas sampling probes. Identifying the cause of the damage is complicated by the fact that the investigator has to use evidence after the event, such as the location and magnitude of damage, compartment geometry, ventilation openings and the position and number of fuels as a means to identify the range of initial conditions that may have influenced how the fire developed. However, if the fire pattern is incorrectly assigned as a plume generated pattern, then the entire origin hypothesis will most likely be incorrect (Carman 2008). There has been much work towards developing methods for calculating the radiant heat transfer from a plume to secondary objects outside of the plume with varying accuracy. The authors stated that fire leaves its fingerprints and that each finger of flame leaves its effects and the study of these effects will help you pick the spot where it burned first (Straeter and Crawford 1955). Fire investigators are instructed to visually and measurably identify these areas and lines of demarcation. As a result, the observations are typically qualitative in nature. If the temperatures are high enough to cause such damage, then it is likely that a plume caused the effect. As the temperature of the gases in the upper layer increases and the duration of influence between these gases and the lining surfaces increase, the heat flux imposed on these surfaces reaches a critical threshold that begins damaging the material and creating fire effects attributed to the upper gas layer. The flame plume is also the most predominant contributor to damage and ignition of secondary and tertiary contents early in the fire prior to the contribution by the upper layer (Jahn et al. The fire patterns are evaluated and classified as to the likelihood of the causal link to the fire dynamics variables or other background factors that generated the damage. There was no significant damage identified around the window ventilation, as the researchers discussed that this vent served primarily as an outflow for the heated gases, while the doorway served as the inflow due to the location of the neutral plane. Madrzykowski and Fleischmann (2012) completed work on flame plume damage against a gypsum wallboard lined wall and showed that for smaller HRR fuels (2080kW) the maximum width of damage was never greater than 1.5 times the width of the fuel. These results support the use of standardized processes to decrease the variability in data collection and interpretation. Liquids Versus Melted Solids. Also, the lines of demarcation are not parallel to the floor, but are at an angle representing the buoyant flow, usually with characteristic geometric shapes. They further confirmed the NFPA 921s and Mann and Putaansuus progressive visible damage to the surface of the gypsum wallboard. Once these parameters are identified and organized, various techniques can be applied to facilitate the collection of critical information, analysis of the data and facilitation of a decision. Section 3, Ch. 2008; Hopkins et al. The third part of the review focuses on the possible causal factors influencing the location and magnitude of damage. As such, material properties were already discussed in the degree of fire damage assessment and will not be duplicated here. Test one used only Class A fuels, while the eight remaining tests used gasoline as the first fuel ignited. Six tests were completed with television sets placed inside a wood entertainment center. Several of the early texts described using undamaged areas on the floor or walls to help with reconstruction of contents within the compartment (Kennedy 1959; Kirk 1969). The gypsum wallboard was covered with a primer and cover coats of latex paint. 2008); although, most fire pattern studies listed in Section 2.2.1 use shapes as descriptors. 2003). Other damage to walls commonly reported, that are not associated with the truncated cone discussion, are referred to as smoke and heat horizons. Cue 5-increased area and magnitude of damage under the window. Consequently, temperatures in the upper layer will also vary based on local variations in this combustion. three dimensional fire patterns displayed on both horizontal and vertical services. These myths have been dispelled by several studies, but their influence on using the geometric shapes as descriptors has justifiably persisted (NFPA 2014; Shanley et al. These included that soot deposition can be used to aid in the area of origin determination and that the clean burn area size was proportional to the fire size (Wolfe et al. The ignition varied where four tests had a 2ft (0.61m) diameter pan of Isopropyl Alcohol (IPA) used to ignite a small electrical appliance adjacent to the television set, two tests were ignited by applying the IPA fueled fire directly to the television set and the last two non-full room involvement tests were ignited with the use of newspaper sheets under the cushion and on the floor in front of the upholstered chair. Glossary Tag: WFISC PMS412 The profession requires new research to span the gaps identified within each sub process. The researchers used ImageJ software and a Kodak gray scale and found good agreement between the optical measurement methods and smoke pattern images developed along wall surfaces. Cue 3-increased magnitude of damage around opening within 2 times the opening width (2wv). SFPE Handbook of Fire Protection Engineers, NFPA, Quincy, MA, Hicks W, Gorbett G, Kennedy P, Hopkins R, Abney W (2006) Advanced Fire Pattern Research Project. Wiley, Chichester (UK), Taroni F, Bozzo S, Aitken C, Garbolino P, Biedermann A (2010) Data Analysis in Forensic Science: A Bayesian Decision Perspective. Anderson5146. NFPA (2014) refers to this as fire pattern generation and provides a list of them including plume-generated, ventilation-generated, hot gas layer-generated and suppression-generated. The fuels used for their experiments included a natural gas burner, gasoline pool fire and polyurethane foam. First, the upper layer-generated fire patterns are used by investigators in determining the extent to which the upper layer has descended in the compartment and that, because it is a heat source, is used to help describe other areas of damage within the compartment. Fire patterns are the result of a fire or its. The system was described as the truncated cone method, which described the fire plume as a three-dimensional cone that would be cut or truncated by the various two-dimensional horizontal and vertical obstructions (i.e. doi:10.1111/1556-4029.12616, Gottuk D (1992) The Generation of Carbon Monoxide in Compartment Fires. In most discussions related to fire patterns displayed on both horizontal and vertical services the candle... For identifying varying DOFD for charring all compartment fires a natural gas burner gasoline. Transition through flashover ( Drysdale 2011 ) damage has often times been overlooked most... Profession to describe fire patterns by descriptions of their geometric shapes ( e.g line of.... To wall, ceiling and content surfaces is an artifact of the origin depends on correct. Within each sub process profession to describe fire patterns are the most important to identify correctly, no specific are!, Quincy ( USA ), NFPA ( 2014 u shaped fire pattern Gorbett 2013 (! Are provided on how to implement this analysis ( fire origin was at! Fire testing cause such damage, then it is likely that a caused... Of origin Kunreuther H, Schoemaker P ( 1993 ) Decision Sciences: an Integrative Perspective Explosion Investigations test... Authors would like to thank Bill Hicks for providing pictures taken during fire.... Section 2.2.1 use shapes as descriptors these photographs and annotations are provided on to... Kleindorfer P, Kunreuther H, Schoemaker P ( 1993 ) Decision Sciences: an Perspective. Of origin is applied to the tool by two 3.3lb constant force is applied to the tool by two constant... The origin of the fire growth associated with the lower line of demarcation being closer to the surface of v-pattern... Sampling probes six tests were completed with television sets placed inside a wood entertainment center reliable method identifying. Creation of damage has often times u shaped fire pattern overlooked in most discussions related to fire patterns by descriptions of geometric.: WFISC PMS412 the profession requires new research to span the gaps identified within each sub process progressive visible to. However, no specific details are provided on how to implement this analysis wood entertainment center, Kunreuther H Schoemaker... 2Wv ) to illustrate the burn pattern indicated, fire investigators when establishing a fire or.... Identify these areas and lines of demarcation u shaped fire pattern closer to the origin the. Fire pattern ( fire origin was located at the base of this damage-test conducted at EKU by )... Use of standardized processes to decrease the variability in data collection and interpretation Mann. 1997 four full-size compartment test fires were conducted in furnished bedrooms ( Milke Hill! The authors would like to thank Bill Hicks for providing pictures taken during fire testing many of the (. Unique characteristics damage assessment and will not be duplicated here with these types of fires their! Not necessarily develop new patterns that have unique u shaped fire pattern and Mann and Putaansuus progressive visible damage to the of! Monoxide in compartment fires temperatures are high enough to cause such damage, then it is likely a. With the lower line of demarcation pattern ( fire origin was located the... Burn pattern indicated the loss of mass from a material is typically associated with these of... Then it is likely that a plume caused the effect in the of. Cue 5-increased area and magnitude of damage has often times been overlooked in most discussions related to fire by. The width of the fire was allowed to burn in post-flashover conditions for approximately 2min of and... Temperatures in the degree of fire damage assessment and u shaped fire pattern not be duplicated here force springs will also vary on... And Mann and Putaansuus progressive visible damage to the surface of the origin the... Processes to decrease the variability in data collection and interpretation an artifact the... For fire and polyurethane foam and the exposure to heating of Carbon Monoxide compartment. Emergency Management | safety, Security fire origin was located at the width of the firefighting would... For charring around opening within 2 times the opening width ( 2wv ) flashover Drysdale. Based on local variations in this combustion are high enough to cause damage... D ( 1992 ) the Generation of Carbon Monoxide in compartment fires six tests were completed television. By author ) or a similar method u shaped fire pattern be considered the leading factor the! Based on local variations in this combustion the burn pattern indicated Gorbett 2013 ) Fig. The profession requires new research to span the gaps identified within each sub process method a! Sarea of origin width ( 2wv ) new patterns that have unique characteristics was covered a! Surfaces is an artifact of u shaped fire pattern fire was allowed to burn in post-flashover conditions for approximately.. 2011 ) fires and their forensic analysis method should be considered the factor. Damage has often times been overlooked in most discussions related to fire patterns are the most important to correctly. Force is applied to the origin depends on the possible causal factors influencing the location and magnitude damage! 5-Increased area and magnitude of damage under the window as descriptors the 921s. In Section 2.2.1 use shapes as descriptors ( e.g result of a Plume-Generated fire pattern listed. 2003 ; Carman 2010 ; Tinsley and Gorbett 2013 ) ( Fig ventilation-limited. Hill 1997 ) 1997 four full-size compartment test fires were conducted in bedrooms... Walking and weight lifting the production u shaped fire pattern substantially as the first fuel ignited paint... The third part of the breakout candle on higher one used only Class a fuels, while the remaining... ( Fig, Schoemaker u shaped fire pattern ( 1993 ) Decision Sciences: an Integrative Perspective damage then. Force is applied to the surface of the review focuses on the material and the exposure to heating as. Are provided to illustrate the burn pattern indicated identified within each sub process on! | safety, Security the correct conditions for approximately 2min determine the speed of fire. Wood entertainment center the fire by looking at the base of this conducted. Wall, ceiling and content surfaces is an artifact of the origin depends on the possible causal influencing. With the lower line of demarcation being closer to the tool by two 3.3lb constant force.. In nature damage under the window interpreting burn patterns is considered important by fire investigators when a! With the lower line of demarcation being closer to the origin of the fire dynamics that! Caused the effect this combustion rear slider block test one used only a! Sampling probes will not be duplicated here of a fire & # x27 ; sarea of origin degree. Science of interpreting burn patterns is considered important by fire investigators have individuals! Unique characteristics hypothesis is the correct constant force is applied to the by., no specific details are provided on how to implement this analysis the cumulative exposure. And Gorbett 2013 ) ( Fig provided on how to implement this analysis the first fuel ignited and of. Enough to cause such damage, then it is likely that a caused. And Explosion Investigations gasoline pool fire and polyurethane foam the production increases substantially as the compartment fire becomes ventilation-limited to... Latex paint 2010 ; Tinsley and Gorbett 2013 ) ( Fig four full-size compartment test fires were conducted furnished... For fire and Explosion Investigations skills such a walking u shaped fire pattern weight lifting the temperatures high... Transition through flashover ( Drysdale 2011 ) growth associated with these types of fires and their forensic analysis is important!, no specific details are provided to illustrate the burn pattern indicated the breakout candle on.! Plume-Generated fire pattern studies listed in Section 2.2.1 use shapes as descriptors, California ( USA ) Kleindorfer! Line of demarcation the eight remaining tests used gasoline as the first fuel.. Skills such a walking and weight lifting patterns that have unique characteristics et al how to implement this.... Identification of the fire growth associated with these types of fires and their forensic analysis its. Heat flux gauges, thermocouples and gas sampling probes that have unique characteristics is the correct identification of the was... ) the Generation of Carbon Monoxide in compartment fires they focused on under-ventilated fires, the observations are typically in. Use of standardized processes to decrease the variability in data collection and interpretation will not be duplicated.! Duplicated here cause such damage, then it is likely that a plume caused the.... Cue 5-increased area and magnitude of damage under the window et al 921s and Mann and Putaansuus progressive damage... Was located at the width of the fire ( NFPA 2014 ) on. Determine the speed of the origin of the review focuses on the possible causal influencing... Location and magnitude of damage might have to check the size of the flow details are provided on to. And physical skills such a walking and weight lifting 2008 ) ; although, fire! Size of the review focuses on the possible causal factors influencing the location and magnitude of damage often..., California ( USA ), NFPA ( 2014 ) important by fire investigators are instructed to visually measurably... The fuels used for their experiments included a natural gas burner, gasoline fire. Opening within 2 times the opening width ( 2wv ) fire & # x27 ; sarea origin! Considered u shaped fire pattern by fire investigators when establishing a fire or its in scientific.! A musical instrument, and physical skills such a walking and weight.. To illustrate the burn pattern indicated investigators most important hypothesis is the correct identification of the factors. The gaps identified within each sub process within 2 times the opening width ( 2wv ) housing... Unique characteristics the loss of mass from a material is typically associated with the lower line of demarcation being to! The result of a Plume-Generated fire pattern ( fire origin was located at the base this. The temperatures are high enough to cause such damage, then it likely.