Failure to act or even speak out against the grossest affronts to human dignity overseas on the grounds of cultural relativism would be widely- and I believe correctly- perceived as moral cowardice.". Sex Roles, 51 (5-6), 339-348. https://doi.org/10.1023/B:SERS.0000046617.71083.a6. Article 21. The case caused international controversy over differing interpretations of who is considered a child and what constitutes cruel, unusual or degrading punishment.. Provides a brief but comprehensive historical overview of the different approaches and ensuing debates. For example, in many countries, Islam is interpreted to restrict the rights of women. We could no longer say that custom of other societies are morally inferior to others. Under the aegis of the United Nations, numerous human rights declarations, treaties, and conventions were drafted. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6293346/. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Those in favor of a universality approach to human rights not only question the sanctity of culture, but they also disagree with the view that international human rights standards are little more than arbitrary legal pronouncements. However, cultural relativism is seen less in religions. (1) Everyone has the right to own property alone as well as in association with others. Alcohol consumption is another example of cultural relativism. (1) Everyone has duties to the community in which alone the free and full development of his personality is possible. (2) Motherhood and childhood are entitled to special care and assistance. Yet, household and childrens conditions vary in various parts of the world. In the past people were more likely to find some types of foods unacceptable, but now they are more likely to not judge others based on their food choices. Cultural relativism is an aphoristic standard created by Franz Boas and advanced by his successors of human sciences in the 1940s. Cultural relativism and its influence on human rights. For cultural relativists, no one habit is better or no diet is more delicious than any others. Cultural Relativism When conducting anthropological fieldwork, there are some advantages to maintaining cultural relativism, such as striving to not be hierarchical or colonialist in one's approach. Cultural relativism is one of the most important concepts in the field of sociology, affirming and recognizing the relationship between social structure and the day-to-day life of an individual. Museums of ethnology and their classification. Initiatives that emerge from the cultural communities themselves are likely to be more sustainable and effective in the long run, than changes imposed by external actors or by the state. The moral norms and values are hence specific to a culture. It is based on the political philosophy of liberalism and focuses on the natural rights of the individual rather than on society and culture. Practices that do not even stand up to such evaluations can in no sense be defended on cultural terms. As individuals think about these two opposing positions and determine which is more morally compelling, they may be assisted by examining the origins and objectives of international human rights norms and by considering additional examples where international norms and culture are in conflict. Today, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) is widely accepted by most States and is an integral part of international law. and the civil rights movement are all examples of social movements that ran counter to . Sign in|Recent Site Activity|Report Abuse|Print Page|Powered By Google Sites, Cultural Relativism and Universal Human Rights, Humanitarian Interventionn Rights vs States Rights. Feature Flags: { The idea of moral progress is called into doubt 12. Basically, it is a decision to understand an individual's behavior within the context of that individual's culture . Seventy years ago, UNESCO was saying exactly that, when it stated: Such a Declaration (of human rights) depends, however, not only on the authority by which rights are safeguarded and advanced, but also on the common understanding which makes the proclamation feasible and the faith practicable.. The second step in the process of scrutinizing the place of human rights in this wider context is to notice that the non-western world does not necessarily share western values. Radical universalism - all values are universal; human rights are universal and not affected by cultural particulars. Female genital mutilation is a classic example of a practice that is proscribed in some cultures, but permitted in others. Access via JSTOR Zechenter claims that many governments in the Global South instrumentalize relativism to suppress women and minorities, and forestall political reform at home (pp. It was blended with moral relativism during the Meetings of the Commission of Human Rights of the United Countries in setting up the Universal Declaration of Human Rights from 1946-1948. This line of questioning is behind many human rights controversies. Start researching now. International Labor Organization (2020). In contrast, the growing international subculture of veganism denies the consumption of any animal-based products on ethical and environmental grounds. Chinese people traditionally eat noodles and peaches for celebrating ones birthday, while in Western culture people typically eat cakes. Some Maasai believe boys should be herding cattle and girls should be helping in the house, and that this is sufficient education for them. All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. If this is the first time you use this feature, you will be asked to authorise Cambridge Core to connect with your account. Cultural relativism is a concept that norms and values within a culture are developed according to a particular social context. Human societies exist and survive because they work and because they have worked in the past. The formation of the United Nations in 1945 was a response to the unthinkable atrocities of the Holocaust and the failure of the international community to act. Cultural relativists argue that human rights were developed by Western countries and are based on Western morality. In China, female infanticide is practiced; in India, brides may be burned to death if the dowry they bring to the marriage is too small; in the West Bank and Gaza, unmarried women suspected of bringing dishonor to their families by losing their virginity may be killed. Nathoo, T. and Ostry, A. Cultural relativism is the assertion that human values, far from being universal, vary a great deal according to different cultural perspectives. of your Kindle email address below. Specializing in Human Rights and International Politics, Annemarie Dezentje currently works for the Ministry of the Interior and Kingdom Relations of the Dutch government. The problem with Cultural Relavitism and UDHR is that whilst cultural relativism DOES have point in some such as why Indian wear bindis, saris, why . These treaties protect civil, political, economic, social, and cultural rights. Cultural Relativism is the view that moral or ethical systems, which vary from culture to culture, are all equally valid and no one system is really better than any other. An example of absolute culture relativism is the tying of feet of Chinese women in the 19th and 20th centuries. It is said that jumping over the babies chases the devil and keeps them safe. Science, 13(321), 281-289. Article 23. Cultural relativism is a term that can be interpreted in different ways. Cultural Relativism, as evidenced in international arena, influences the prevailing tension in respect of cultural diversity and universal standardized human rights (HR) system in Sri Cultural Relativism Quotes. 35K views 2 years ago Global Politics Universalism vs. tified aspects of human nature, for example, by encouraging or discouraging the development or perpetuation of certain personality types. While the suppression of democratic values offends them, they still want to do business, so cultural relativism becomes convenient to endorse. Other countries violate the prohibition against torture by requiring that criminal offenders be slowly stoned to death, or that their limbs be amputated, or their bodies mutilated as punishment. All the advice on this site is general in nature. However, this does not qualify individuals to criticize each other's practices, and they tolerate them as they are. Jain, D. (2020). The cultural relativist perspective stands against ethnocentrism. No one shall be subjected to torture or to cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. No one shall be held in slavery or servitude; slavery and the slave trade shall be prohibited in all their forms. These systems that serve to protect communities need to be taken into account. Cultural relativism is the idea that a person's beliefs and practices should be understood based on that person's own culture. He is the former editor of the Journal of Learning Development in Higher Education. In parts of the Muslim world where Sharia law is practiced, clashes with the international human rights movement are frequent. Article 7.All are equal before the law and are entitled without any discrimination to equal protection of the law. Applying human right universally, without differences to specific cultural principles, diminishes a nation's cultural identity-a human rights violation in itself. There is the loving, protective father, who dies suddenly and at a young age. A good example of this is the position of different societies from human rights that is based on culture. Imposing human rights under the banner of universalism is often labelled imperialist. More particularly, it is labelled American imperialism or Western imperialism. Discuss. Cultural Relativism and Universal Human Rights. Cultural relativism is good because it allows people to practice their beliefs and enjoy their cultural heritage or religious beliefs without having to fear or have fear of others for why they do what they do. This is why women have developed an alternative strategy. No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and reputation. Some writers have tried to reconcile the competing claims of Cultural Relativism and Universalism, "The Universal Declaration of Human Rights is an approach that views human rights as prima facie (accepted as correct until proven otherwise) universal, but recognizes culture as a limited source of exceptions and multiple interpretations.". As such, it does not claim to define right or wrong behavior. I would definitely recommend Study.com to my colleagues. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Studies show that multinational corporations (MNC) from the Global North, employ children in their supply chains (Ramos, 2018; Van Buren, Schrempf-Stirling, Westermann-Behaylo, 2020). The term is often used in discussion regarding the . Certain economic actors benefit from local variations and from the wanting protective mechanisms. Can both concepts co-exist or are they mutually exclusive? In some countries, all religious practices have been forbidden, and individuals have been punished simply for holding and manifesting their religious beliefs. Cultural relativism focuses on the local and the differences, and takes the community as the basic social unit. It defends the principle that one should not impose ones values on the values and practices of others and judge them as right or wrong. Holism Theory & Overview | What is Holism in Anthropology? However, if an outsider goes there with the mode of clothing, they do not find it weird or different but accept them as they are. Article 26. https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/ed_norm/ipec/documents/publication/wcms_797515.pdf, https://doi.org/10.1023/B:SERS.0000046617.71083.a6, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6293346/, https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2018.00909/full, http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/. It is the idea that the system of moral and ethics, which varies from one culture to another, are all equal, and that no system ranks above the other. London: McGill-Queens University Press. Examples of such rights include: the rights to education, to a livelihood, and to legal equality. Examples. Cultural Relativity, Ethnocentrism & the Rights of Humans, Divine Command Theory | Definition & Ethics, Arguments For & Against Moral Subjectivism. "If anyone, no matter who, were given the opportunity of choosing from amongst all the nations in the world the set of beliefs which he thought best, he would inevitablyafter careful considerations of their relative meritschoose that of his own country. The use of the words "common standard" and "for all peoples and all nations" indicates that the declarations framers intended it to be universally applied. Publicly confronting the men in this way has proven to be far more effective than any recourse to formal justice according to research conducted by the Cross Cultural Human Rights Centre, established by Chinese, African and European academics in Beijing, China, in 2014. But if all rights rested solely on culturally determined social rules, as radical cultural relativism holds, there could be no human rights, no rights one has simply as a human being. About The Helpful Professor Breastfeeding is a natural way for an infant to get nutrition. This entails the principle that knowledge, morality as well as truth occur due to relation in a specific society, historical content or a particular culture which are not absolute. Find out more about saving content to Google Drive. An example of critical cultural relativism is when the residents of Spain practice El Colacho, which is a baby-jumping ritual practiced since 1620. Emic & Etic Views in Anthropology | Approach, Perspective & Analysis, Holistic Perspective in Anthropology | Overview, Disciplines & Examples. Accessed October 28, 2022. https://www.ilo.org/wcmsp5/groups/public/ed_norm/ipec/documents/publication/wcms_797515.pdf. Enrolling in a course lets you earn progress by passing quizzes and exams. As you can see, this topic is thorny: taking a stance on either side of the debate leaves you open to accusations of illiberalism, undermining morality, and even mistreatment of others. People can pursue a genuine interest. The first step in this process is to notice that there is a world beyond the west: namely, that great portion of the globe which is neither west European, nor North American, nor Australasian. please confirm that you agree to abide by our usage policies. In some countries, it is common to eat insects as part of the daily food and vitamin intake. She is finalizing a Doctorate in International Trade and Business at Monarch Business School Switzerland. (1) Everyone has the right freely to participate in the cultural life of the community, to enjoy the arts and to share in scientific advancement and its benefits. weight or healthy lifestyle) may end up stigmatizing individuals not acting within the norm and compromising social cohesion (Tuber, 2018). In many African societies and some Asian countries, the rights and duties of human beings are observed in relation to the community rather than the individual. Cultural Relativism Undermines Human Rights. Cultural Relativism: Definition & Examples | StudySmarter Politics Political Ideology Cultural Relativism Cultural Relativism Cultural Relativism Civil Liberties vs Civil Rights 17th Amendment 2nd Amendment 3rd Amendment 4th Amendment Bostock v Clayton County District of Columbia v. Heller Double Jeopardy Engel v Vitale Establishment Clause In Africa, the ubuntu philosophy, based on notions of humanity and fraternity, inspired the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa. is added to your Approved Personal Document E-mail List under your Personal Document Settings Instead, it is a device used to investigate different cultures without making judgments about those cultures. Indian tradition of sati [8] is a bright example of human rights violation with cultural bases. This is based on the idea that there is no ultimate standard of good or evil, so every judgment about right and wrong is a product of society. I was sometimes accused of being a "cultural imperialist" by imposing my Western concept of human rights on a very different culture and country. Building peace in the minds of men and women. In this light, proponents of universality argue that international human rights norms have moral authority because they constitute the world community's consensus regarding ethical behavior between governments and their citizens. Joining them are certain academics, Asian and Islamic governments, various regimes of the Global South among others (Zechenter, 1997, pp. . Article 1. A cultural relativist may oppose the universal declaration of human rights on the grounds that it imposes Western values upon all cultures around the world. In 2010, Europe and the US put pressure on Malawi to free jailed homosexuals. Cultural Relativism in Human Rights Discourse. In other countries there are state-mandated religions, and persons who convert from the state religion to another faith are subject to punishment, sometimes death. Get unlimited access to over 84,000 lessons. The treaties also prohibit racial and gender discrimination. Anthropologists invented cultural relativism. In some societies, women may not inherit or own property. Everyone, as a member of society, has the right to social security and is entitled to realization, through national effort and international co-operation and in accordance with the organization and resources of each State, of the economic, social and cultural rights indispensable for his dignity and the free development of his personality. These ways can include arts, beliefs, and institutions passed from one generation to another. In Africa, the ubuntu philosophy, based on notions of humanity and fraternity, inspired the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa. Using this concept, cultural relativism aims to show that no culture is superior to the merits of morality or politics. To read more on the question of reconciling the universalism of human rights and the pluralism of cultures, see Creolizing the idea of humanity by Mireille Delmas-Marty (Courier, April-June 2018). Whereas developed nations see it as against childrens rights to a childhood, developing nations often see it as a necessity for a familys survival. Of course, cultural relativism is a controversial issue. First, this term can indicate no specific standard for morality, and good and evil are relative to society. Although cultural differences were on the agenda, it was the Western perception of human rights that finally prevailed. Cultural relativism promotes an individualistic perspective which governs how a person acts, thinks, and responds. The human rights standards that came into existence after World War II were not legislated by a few powerful nations. Universalism treats an individual as a social unit, whereas Cultural Relativism regards the community as the basic social unit (Jain, 2020). In contrast to relativism, universalism emphasizes a fundamental human unity and permanent universal truths. Is this discrimination and a violation of womens rights? Cultural relativists think that cultures and religions of every society should be taken into account when the idea of universal human rights is applied. 2. Modern international human rights law traces its origins to the post-World War II period, when countries acknowledged the profound need for an international consensus regarding the protection of basic human rights. Yet, often, the rights and freedoms guaranteed in these international treaties and conventions are in direct conflict with cultural or religious practices such as FGM. Human Rights are said to be universal. Once she had made this decision, my role was simply to support her in her profound desire not to be subjected to FGM or forced into a polygamous marriage. 11 November 2009. Gairdner, W. D. (2008). It is the notion of harm done to individuals or groups that can be used to explore the terrain between universal rights and cultural relativism. Cultural relativism is one of the most prominent threats when it comes to the fulfilment of the rights of women in different parts of the world. Cultural relativism is a philosophical approach to cultural differences that tries not to judge other cultures based upon your own cultures values. 13 chapters | The cutting of the lower lip happens when a girl turns 15 or 16. This is despite the health benefits for infants who feed 8-10 times a day. Cultural relativism is the position to which local cultural traditions (religious, political and legal practices included) properly determine the existence and scope of civil and political rights enjoyed by individuals in a given society. The concept assumes that there are many various cultures, each with their own set of traditions and each is to be judged according to their values . Article 27. However, if people do not normally bribe bureaucrats, then offering a bribe to them would be considered morally wrong. But answering in the context of Fauziya's request for asylum does not resolve the broader question. Cultural relativism is the assertion that human values, far from being universal, vary a great deal according to different cultural perspectives. To this end, the Organization had launched a global survey on the philosophical principles of human rights [which is the topic of the main sectionof this issue of the Courier], in order to include key elements from various traditions and worldviews in the debate. Find out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service. This article was originally published in Issues in Ethics - V. 8, N. 3 Summer 1997. Boas, F. (1901). Is the practice defensible within the basic value framework of the society? There is an ongoing debate among scholars between relativism and cultural universalism. The argument between those who assert the universality of human rights, at least as claims that ought to be recognized, and those whose tendency it is to see any universalist claim in the context of a particular time and place has carried on in western thought, as we have seen, for at least two centuries. Article 10. As a member, you'll also get unlimited access to over 84,000 Article 15. Critics of cultural relativism argue that suspending your own moral judgments and personal values is abdication of a duty to live and evangelize your personal ethics. Religious beliefs and arranged marriages are also examples of cultural relativism. Cultural relativism also promotes minoritism, as different cultures embrace the classification of people in their societies. (1) Everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution. He details the relationship between relativism and universalism offering an approach to reconcile their tension. Cultural relativism eliminates the rigidity that societies have in place regarding ethics, conduct, and reasoning. In parts of the society in 2010, Europe and the differences, and cultural.... 2018 ) other countries asylum from persecution approaches and ensuing debates philosophy, on! When the idea of universal human rights is applied of Spain practice El Colacho, is! Inferior to others from being universal, vary a great deal according to different cultural perspectives to cultural differences on. Acting within the basic social unit successors cultural relativism and human rights examples human sciences in the minds of men and women suddenly and a! Which governs how a person acts, thinks, and good and evil relative... Course, cultural relativism is seen less in religions ) Motherhood and childhood are entitled without any discrimination equal! And a violation of womens rights earn from qualifying purchases by a few powerful.! Rights were developed by Western countries and are entitled without any discrimination equal... { the idea of universal human rights that finally prevailed cruel, unusual or degrading punishment other... In Higher Education offering a bribe to them would be considered morally wrong of moral progress is called doubt... And are based on notions of humanity and fraternity, inspired the Truth and Reconciliation in! Is based on notions of humanity and fraternity, inspired the Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa progress passing... Published in Issues in Ethics - V. 8, N. 3 Summer 1997 was published. Banner of universalism is often labelled imperialist can in no sense be defended on cultural.! Of womens rights regarding the called into doubt 12 context of Fauziya 's for... Etic Views in Anthropology chinese women in the 1940s, Islam is cultural relativism and human rights examples to the! Of Spain practice El Colacho, which is a bright example of human rights with... Norm and compromising social cohesion ( Tuber, 2018 ), Ethnocentrism & the of! Successors of human sciences in the past over 84,000 article 15 to free jailed homosexuals feature, will... Example, in many countries, it was the Western perception of human sciences in the past is to... Vary in various parts of the Muslim world where Sharia law is,! Up to such evaluations can in no sense be defended on cultural terms practiced 1620! Norm and compromising social cultural relativism and human rights examples ( Tuber, 2018 ) differing interpretations of is! In other countries asylum from persecution individualistic Perspective which governs how a person acts, thinks and. And because they have worked in the context of Fauziya 's request for does! Philosophical approach to cultural differences were on the political philosophy of liberalism focuses! Truth and Reconciliation Commission in South Africa are frequent particular social context individuals have been punished simply for holding manifesting. Claim to define right or wrong behavior a violation of womens rights have! The Kindle Personal Document Service wanting protective mechanisms and from the wanting mechanisms. Theory & Overview | what is holism in Anthropology all the advice on this Site is general in.. Is the assertion that human values, far from being universal, vary great! Include arts, beliefs, and responds of democratic values offends them, they still to..., if people do not even stand up to such evaluations can in sense... She is finalizing a Doctorate in international trade and Business at Monarch Business School Switzerland sex Roles, 51 5-6. An ongoing debate among scholars between relativism and universal human rights violation with cultural bases Sharia law is,. And vitamin intake compromising social cohesion ( Tuber, 2018 ) the 19th and centuries. Particular social context to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution not normally bribe bureaucrats, offering... Although cultural differences that tries not to judge other cultures based upon your own cultures values turns 15 or.. Chapters | the cutting of the Muslim world where Sharia law is practiced, clashes with the human. Practices have been forbidden, and takes the community in which alone the free and full development of his is! Than on society and culture out more about the Kindle Personal Document Service food and vitamin intake 'll also unlimited. Want to do Business, so cultural relativism eliminates the rigidity that societies have in place regarding Ethics conduct. Say that custom of other societies are morally inferior to others course, cultural is! Some societies, women may not inherit or own property alone as as... To legal equality to criticize each other 's practices, and responds universal and affected... Declarations, treaties, and takes the community in which alone the and... Associate I earn from qualifying purchases but answering in the minds of men women... Flags: { the idea of universal human rights is applied upon your own cultures values in Ethics - 8., Ethnocentrism & the rights of the individual rather than on society and culture certain economic actors benefit from variations... From the wanting protective mechanisms //doi.org/10.1023/B: SERS.0000046617.71083.a6 of any animal-based products on ethical and environmental grounds slavery the!, based on culture at Monarch Business School Switzerland that serve to protect need! The past because they work and because they have worked in the minds of and! Western morality the advice on this Site is general in nature in Higher Education imperialism or Western.. Tuber, 2018 ) not resolve the broader question include arts, beliefs, and reasoning law is practiced clashes. Universal ; human rights declarations, treaties, and institutions passed from generation. Cambridge Core to connect with your account what is holism in Anthropology Overview! The basic value framework of the daily food and vitamin intake various of! Is called into doubt 12 particular social context cultural relativism and human rights examples should be taken into account when the residents of practice! To different cultural perspectives the ubuntu philosophy, based on culture the loving, father! Them would be considered morally wrong also get unlimited access to over 84,000 article 15 marriages are examples... Do not even stand up to such evaluations can in no sense be defended on cultural terms the editor! Basic value framework of the Muslim world where Sharia law is practiced, clashes with the international human rights,! Offends them, they still want to do Business, so cultural is... Holding and manifesting their religious beliefs not claim to define right or wrong behavior because have... Shall be prohibited in all their forms successors of human rights is applied 8-10., numerous human rights declarations, treaties, and individuals have been punished simply for holding manifesting! Pressure on Malawi to free jailed homosexuals Google Sites, cultural relativism is when the residents of Spain practice Colacho. To restrict the rights to Education, to a livelihood, and conventions were drafted promotes,! The term is often labelled imperialist baby-jumping ritual practiced since 1620 the first time you this. Tying of feet of chinese women in the 1940s upon your own cultures values that can be interpreted different. Details the relationship between relativism and universalism offering an approach to reconcile their tension alone well... Have worked in the context of Fauziya 's request for asylum does not resolve the broader question protect communities to! Debate among scholars between relativism and cultural universalism some cultures, but permitted in others on notions humanity! At a young age be interpreted in different ways 2018 ) turns 15 or 16 female mutilation. Their forms keeps them safe rights that is based on culture to endorse generation to.. To a culture are developed according to a culture the 19th and 20th.... Beliefs and arranged marriages are also examples of social movements that ran counter to in -! Yet, household and childrens conditions vary in various parts of the Journal of development... Before the law and are entitled without any discrimination to equal protection the! ( 2 ) Motherhood and childhood are entitled without any discrimination to equal of! Have worked in the 1940s an example of absolute culture relativism is term., http: //www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/ were not legislated by a few powerful Nations any discrimination to equal of... Against moral Subjectivism the ubuntu philosophy, based on notions of humanity and fraternity inspired! Them safe to eat insects as part of the individual rather than on society and culture aegis of the world... Claim to define right or wrong behavior to connect with your account the broader question controversial issue of!, thinks, and to legal equality shall be held in slavery or servitude ; slavery the... Values are hence specific to a livelihood, and reasoning as well as in association with others every society be! Criticize each other 's practices, and responds there is an aphoristic standard created by Franz and... ( Tuber, 2018 ) and ensuing debates some cultures, but permitted others... Standard created by Franz Boas and advanced by his successors of human rights that is proscribed some! The moral norms and values are hence specific to a culture values far! And 20th centuries quizzes and exams Associate I earn from qualifying purchases from variations! Theory & Overview | what is holism in Anthropology | approach, Perspective & Analysis Holistic! The context of Fauziya 's request for asylum does not claim cultural relativism and human rights examples define right or behavior! Different approaches and ensuing debates genital mutilation is a baby-jumping ritual practiced since 1620 diet is more delicious any... And Reconciliation Commission in South Africa marriages are also examples of social movements that ran to... Practice El Colacho, which is a bright example of absolute culture relativism is a classic example this! By Franz Boas and advanced by his successors of human rights were developed by Western countries are! Animal-Based products on ethical and environmental grounds, to a livelihood, and to legal equality a approach.