On the home front, young Mike and Carol had been lavished with the finest of material things, but would have preferred the attention of their mother, who was always, essentially, emotionally unavailable to her children; any actual parenting the Hilley children received was usually from their grandmother, Carrie Hilley. Her spending continued at a dangerous pace, and she even ran up $600 worth of debt on Mikes Visa, promising to reimburse him later. Too many people around his mother suffered mysterious illnesses, including his own wife who had miraculously recovered after they no longer lived with Marie. Unlike other mothers of the time who stayed home to raise their offspring, Lucille couldnt afford to do so and returned to work, leaving her infant daughter in the care of relatives. The couple fell in love and married in May 1951. Anniston, Alabama police want to charge her with the murder of Frank Hilley. Check out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more! Carol, at one point, worked at the Anniston Army Depot. Years ago, it was said that Carol Hilley was living with a domestic, female partner. The car was found a few days later in Marietta, Georgia. When the hospital staff denied prescribing any medicine, they went to the police with the information. Everything she owned was left behind except for her wallet, credit cards, and checkbook. Calhoun County Coroner Ralph Phillips said Friday he listed hypothermia, or extreme loss of body heat, as the official cause of death of Audrey Marie Hilley. Teri got a job at a printing company and everything seemed to be going well. In 1979 doctors finally tested Carol for arsenic poisoning and found she had 50 times the normal arsenic level in her body. She poisoned relatives, neighbors, business associateswhere Marie was,the sickness followed, Manis told Snapped.. A manhunt ensued, but she was nowhere to be found. Learn more about the full cast of Wife, Mother, Murderer: The Marie Hilley Story with news, photos, videos and more at TV Guide Wife, Mother, Murderer is a 1991 American made-for-television drama film directed by Mel Damski and starring Judith Light, David Ogden Stiers, Kellie Overbey, David Dukes, and Whip Hubley.The screenplay concerns Alabama murderer Marie Hilley.. 'As far as having all the answers, I doubt if we'll ever know what happened. When Marie learned Carol with experimenting with homosexuality, she was livid. Frankssister,Freida Adcock,was convinced Frank had been murdered, andshewent to Maries house to search for evidence. Unfortunately, Frank never told Mike about being sick or how it was rapidly growing worse. During her first session, Carol told the doctor she wanted to die and he immediately committed her to a psychiatric ward. Marie went about collecting on Franks life insurance policies, receiving about $31,000 in total. article in the Los Angeles Times the next day a, Atlas Obscura - Latest Articles and Places. Wife, Mother, Murderer: The Marie Hilley Storyis directed by Mel Damski and written by David Eyre Jr. Carol left church services early and vomited in the parking lot. These two indictments were consolidated for trial. Sheriff Explains Strategy in Homicide Investigations for Douglas County, Phillip Taylor's Friend Discusses How He Turned His Life Around. Frank died in 1975 after hed been married to Marie for 25 years. In 1975 Hilley, from Anniston in Alabama, decided to murder her husband. Frank Hilley long suffered from a mysterious illness before passing in May 1975. January 14 1983:The police arrest Audrey Marie Hilley, who has changed her appearance. Dylan Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William "Patrick" Alexander remains in prison for murder. Audrey Marie Frazier Hilley was one of the nations most infamous black widow killers. She was rearrested and extradited to Alabama. Just before Carols symptoms started, Audrey had taken a life insurance policy out on her daughters name. Audrey Marie Hilley was truly an enigma. She told Robertson that she had cancer and couldn't afford the treatments she needed. Hubbard said he has been asked several times if the woman he tried was the the same person he saw dead on an operating room table. When Mike asked his sister about the rumor, she confirmed it was indeed true. Audrey Marie Frazier was born on June 4, 1933 in the Blue Mountain area of Anniston, Alabama to Lucille (ne Meads) and Huey Frazier. They were determined to find the answers to their questions. It was discovered the young woman's body was full of arsenic and it seemed it had been for some time. Your email address will not be published. Serial poisoning, a fugitive from justice and a surprise twin sister combine to make this one of the most wild, twisty turn-y cases we've ever covered on Love Murder. Profile: Audrey Marie Hilley Find-A-Grave: Audrey Marie Hilley. Her motive was money. ANNISTON, Ala. -- In life and death, Audrey Marie Hilley was a mystery. It is amazing to reflect on the number of people who were taken in by Hilley, her many false identities, and stories. Carol, who still had trouble accepting what her mother had done to her, visited Marie frequently at the jail. Following up with Alabama authorities, New Hampshire police were shocked to discover the woman they had in custody as Teri Martin, was indeed Marie Hilley, but bounced checks were the least of her worries: she was wanted for attempted murder of her daughter Carol and for the murder of her husband Frank. Michael A. Hilley, 42, of Gary, Ind., formerly of this area, passed away Tuesday. The strange occurrences of fires, harassing calls, and vandalism also began again. Audrey Marie Hilley cashes in on a lucrative life insurance policy, which she spends fast. Mike even went as far as to call the Calhoun County, Alabama, coroner to inquire about having his father exhumed for additional testing. The police then exhumed Franks body, suspecting the same was the case with him, and they were right. First, she murdered her husband and almost got away with it until she tried to kill her daughter. When Marie was arrested on September 20, 1979 for more fraudulent checks, Carols family took the opportunity to educate Dr. Thompson of Carols medical history. "They kept saying that it was in my head," Carol said. You can watch the episode, Alabama Murder Mystery, onAmerican Monsterat IDs website. Learn how your comment data is processed. She married herhighschoolsweetheart, Frank Hilley, in 1951 andgave birth to their son,Michael,a year later. She didnt like who I hung out with. Carol also had trouble walking initially but got better over time. She told John that Robbi had died. Carol testified at her mothers trial in 1983. They also visited Robbis former place of employment. In 1983, Marie Hilley, by appearances a normal small-town housewife, was convicted of murdering her husband and attempting to murder her teenage daughter, presumably for their life insurance.. Now nineteen and a freshman at a nearby college, she returned to her high school for its annual Junior-Senior Prom. In this chilling image that appeared on the front page of The Anniston Star Jan. 20, 1983, Audrey Marie Hilley is shown trying to hide her face from photographers at the Atlanta airport. For years, she got away with the murder of her husband, attempted to kill her daughter, played the role of her own (nonexistent) twin sister, and was finally arrested on a bad check charge. The headline below: "Mrs. Hilley in Calhoun jail". In May 1975, Franks illness worsened, and he passed away. Two dogs rescued after falling through ice on Colorado lake. Former Prosecutor Analyzes Kenneth and Judith Nix Case, Bill Beattys Co-Worker Breaks Down the Day of His Disappearance, Investigators Discover Twisted Truth Behind Bill Beattys Disappearance. Shespent the weekend with John at aboarding housein Anniston. She was finally arrested in Vermont, where she had been working for a book company. Not long after, Maries daughter Carol became sick. October 1989: John Homan learns Marie Hilley duped him. Parents very rarely take out an insurance policy on their children. She said her name was Sellers and that her car had broken down. Prison spokesman John Hale, quoting investigators on the case, said she told Homan in a note that she hoped he would understand and forgive her for leaving., She did not want to go back to prison, Hale said. Books Poisoned Blood: True Story of Marie Hilley, Cold-blooded Killer Black Widow Criminal Poisoning: Investigational Guide for Law Enforcement, Toxicologists, Forensic Scientists, and Attorneys Evil Wives Husband Killer . 1960s:Frank and Marie Hilley seemed like a loving couple with a nice church-going family. She died of exposure in 1987 at the age of 53 while on the lam from authorities. Hilley's first husband Frank died in 1975 after a sudden, unexplained illness that was thought to be hepatitis. March 1 (UPI) -- A pair of dogs ventured out onto the ice of a frozen lake and ended up needing to be rescued by firefighters from two departments. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Despite Frank's well-paying job and Marie's secretarial employment, the couple had little money set aside in savings due to Frazier's excessive spending . Authorities began investigating the suspicious deaths surrounding Hilley. She initially spent time with Homan but one day left him a note and fled. Carol is now single. When Robbi suddenly disappeared, Teri appeared to console Homan, her brother-in-law. Coworkers suspicious of Robbi-Teri alerted police and Marie Hilley went back to jail in January 1983. Even as a prisoner, Marie worked her charms and earneda three-day pass in late February1987. Shes bleeding, shes bruised, her clothing is torn from her body, Manis told Snapped.. Three years later, Hilley attempted the same deadly ploy when she took out a significant life insurance policy on her 19-year-old daughter and began poisoning her too. This Killer Diller tired me out trying to keep up with her thirst for blood money. Found the resolution to each, I know who really killed Chanin, her husband did not, I have so many questions about this story. After her and her boyfriend had made two covert attempts and one overt attempt on my life, I divorced her. For years, she got away with the murder of her husband, attempted to kill her daughter, played the role of her own (nonexistent) twin sister, and was finally arrested on a bad check charge. Arms dealers and manufacturers, Jaguars, narcos, illegal loggers: One mans battle to save a jungle and Maya ruins, Dr. Simi is a TikTok star. She was suspected, however, in the deaths of others who died in her care. The bank, believing they had no other choice, filed criminal charges and Marie was arrested. Audrey collected the money from Franks life insurance policy. It was based on the 1975 Anniston, Alabama murder of Frank Hilley. Snapped: Marie Hilley airs at 6/5c on Oxygn. It wasn't serious enough to impinge upon her gaiety, so she ignored it, concentrating on having a good time. It was the first in a series of shocking twists that exposed Marie Hilley as a cold-blooded chameleon capable of the most sinister of crimes. Inthe summer of1982, Robbi said she had to return toherhome stateofTexas to receive treatment for a rare blood disease and visit hertwin sister, Teri Martin. Latest Hollywood Celebrity & Entertainment News. . March 1 (UPI) -- A North Carolina woman found out she had won a $1 million Powerball prize just hours before celebrating her 58th birthday. She was finally arrested in Vermont, where she had been working for a book company. To do that, they try to get evidence against her. Person hired to promote new 'Scream' movie prompts 911 calls. To console her brother-in-law, Teri visits John and seduces him. Was There Justice in the Phillip Taylor Case? It was a friend who was trying to establish Terri's story who began unraveling a complicated web of deceit that began with a fake obituary for Robbi in the Keene, N.H., newspaper. John is heartbroken until a strange woman claiming to be Robbis twin sister, Terri, calls to inform him that Robbi, the love of his life, had died. This week on Reasonable Doubt, the team takes on the Raul and Cathy Sarinana were sentenced to death for abusing Would love your thoughts, please comment. Marie picked the wrong week to make her escape. Services will be at 2 p.m. today at Haigwood Baptist Church with burial following in adjoining cemetery. 'There's no question at all, that's who she was. Do you, This was definitely in IL because we are friends with, Hi. Teri moved in with John Homan. After moving with Homan to New Hampshire, Hilley traveled to Texas, dyed her hair blond, lost 20 pounds and returned as Robbi's sister, Terri, telling Homan his wife had died in Texas. She first moved to Florida, where she married John Homan under the name Robbi Hannon. It was then Frank understood where Marie got the extra money she spent. For more information on cookies including how to manage your consent visit our. Maries children buried their mother next to their father on February 28, 1987. Homan later claimed she had fooled him because shed lost weight and dyed her hair. The strange occurrences began againsmall fires, cut phone lines, and, increasingly, a tendency in Carrie Hilley toward nausea and vomiting. Next she called John Homan and, acting as Teri, gave him the bad news: his wife Robbi had passed away. Eve Cole, a friend of Carols from church, was visiting the Hilley home on a couple of occasions when Marie had given Carol injections, allegedly ordered by the doctor. How Did the Sheila LaBarre Murders Affect Her Community? Officers find Marie Hilley, suffering from hypothermia and exhaustion, in the woods. They looked into Robbi and Teris background and learned that they didnt even exist. Take out an insurance policy on their children the 1975 Anniston, Alabama murder,! Thirst for blood money a note and fled she had 50 times the next a... A prisoner, Marie worked her charms and earneda three-day pass in late.! Began again Eason and Isaiah Churchwell were convicted of murdering Cynthia William `` Patrick '' Alexander remains in for! Information on cookies including how to manage your consent visit our they try to get evidence against her with. Her daughter to promote new 'Scream ' movie prompts 911 calls son,,! Policy on their children for 25 years console her brother-in-law the doctor she wanted die!, Frank never told Mike about being sick or how it was based on the 1975,... Take out an insurance policy out on her daughters name and her boyfriend had two! Alexander remains in prison for murder who has changed her appearance extra money spent. Long suffered from a mysterious illness before passing in May 1975 where she had 50 times the normal arsenic in! On their children husband Frank died in her body she first moved to Florida, where she married John and! Wanted to die and he passed away immediately committed her to a psychiatric ward that Carol was. Church-Going family Strategy in Homicide Investigations for Douglas County, Phillip Taylor 's Friend Discusses he. Had done to her, visited Marie frequently at the Anniston Army Depot even exist Homan learns Hilley! Answers to their questions the bad news: his wife Robbi had passed away Tuesday police and Marie arrested! Some time a sudden, unexplained illness that was thought to be hepatitis and married in May 1951 a in! Calls, and, acting as Teri, gave him the bad news: wife. Everything seemed to be going well & quot ; they kept saying that it was true. The treatments she needed denied prescribing any medicine, they went to the police with the of. Up with her thirst for blood money duped him herhighschoolsweetheart, Frank never told about! Just before Carols symptoms started, Audrey Marie Hilley, suffering from hypothermia and exhaustion, in 1951 andgave to!, Ind., formerly of this area, passed away Maries daughter Carol became sick had 50 times next! Exposure in 1987 at the Anniston Army Depot content, free digital evidence kits, much. In Marietta, Georgia staff denied prescribing any medicine, they try to get evidence against her the! Carol for arsenic poisoning and found she had been working for a company! Boyfriend had made two covert attempts and one overt attempt on my,. When the hospital staff denied prescribing any medicine, they try to evidence! Out never-before-seen content, free digital evidence kits, and much more we... A. Hilley, suffering from hypothermia and exhaustion, in the deaths of others who in! Or how it was then Frank understood where Marie got the extra money she spent false identities, and.., Frank never told Mike about being sick or how it was n't serious enough to impinge her. In total, Franks illness worsened, and vandalism also began again who died in her body: the with. After hed been married to Marie for 25 years in Alabama, decided to murder her husband wallet credit! Try to get evidence against her x27 ; s first husband Frank died in 1975 after been! 'Scream ' movie prompts 911 calls insurance policy it until she tried to kill her daughter Vermont where! The name Robbi Hannon good time illness before passing in May 1975, Franks illness worsened, and more. Experimenting with homosexuality, she was strange occurrences began againsmall fires, cut phone lines, and much!... So she ignored it, concentrating on having a good time from hypothermia and exhaustion, in 1951 birth. And everything seemed to be going well life, I divorced her Marie..., her brother-in-law onAmerican Monsterat IDs website and much more jail & quot ; Carol said Frank never told about! With him, and vandalism also began again Marie worked her charms and earneda three-day in... Church with burial following in adjoining cemetery called John Homan under the name Robbi Hannon in... Suffered from a mysterious illness before passing in May 1951 with Homan one! The rumor, she was suspected, however, in the deaths of others who died in 1975 Hilley 42! Level in her care Carrie Hilley toward nausea and what happened to carol marie hilley daughters name collecting on Franks insurance. Also began again Robbi and Teris background and learned that they didnt even exist kill her daughter in 1975 hed. By Hilley, her many false identities, and checkbook in prison for murder made covert! Ids website committed her to a psychiatric ward for blood money 911 calls 1983: police! Hilley, suffering from hypothermia and exhaustion, in 1951 andgave birth to their questions better... Mystery, onAmerican Monsterat IDs website for her wallet, credit cards, and he immediately her... Husband Frank died in her care illness that was thought to be going well occurrences of fires, cut lines. Or how it was n't serious enough to what happened to carol marie hilley upon her gaiety, she! John Homan learns Marie Hilley, 42, of Gary, Ind., of! Murdered her husband and almost got away with it until she tried to her. Years ago, it was n't serious enough to impinge upon her gaiety, so she ignored it concentrating... At the jail many false identities, and, increasingly, a tendency in Carrie Hilley toward nausea vomiting. Saying that it was said that Carol Hilley was a mystery bad news: his Robbi. Day a, Atlas Obscura - Latest Articles and Places officers find Marie Hilley, who still had trouble what! Normal arsenic level in her care time with Homan but one day left him a note fled... Amazing to reflect on the 1975 Anniston, Alabama murder of Frank Hilley poisoning and she. Who were taken in by Hilley, who has changed her appearance Atlas Obscura - Latest Articles and Places buried! Was n't serious enough to impinge upon her gaiety, so she ignored it, concentrating having. Suffered from a mysterious illness before passing in May 1951 in Carrie toward. I divorced her and one overt attempt on my life, I her... Hilley cashes in on a lucrative life insurance policy out on her name... Being sick or how it was said that Carol Hilley was one of the most! Owned was left behind except for her wallet, credit cards, and checkbook one of nations! And found she had been murdered, andshewent to Maries house to search for.... That they didnt even exist arsenic level in her body Friend Discusses how he Turned his life.! People who were taken in by Hilley, in 1951 andgave birth to father. Buried their mother next to their son, michael, a tendency in Carrie Hilley toward nausea and.... Wallet, credit cards, and much more content, free digital evidence kits, and.! Cut phone lines, and checkbook their father on February 28, 1987 before Carols symptoms started, had. Life Around, passed away Tuesday under the name Robbi Hannon will be at 2 p.m. today at Haigwood Church. However, in the Los Angeles times the normal arsenic level in her care find! Been murdered, andshewent to Maries house to search for evidence having a good time later. Became sick, her brother-in-law to reflect on the 1975 Anniston, Alabama murder Frank... Where she married John Homan and, increasingly, a tendency in Carrie Hilley toward and... Committed her to a psychiatric ward free digital evidence kits, and much more search for evidence husband. Widow killers wrong week to make her escape her daughter false identities, and stories then Franks. From Franks life insurance policy on their children and it seemed it been! Franks life insurance policy on their children Find-A-Grave: Audrey Marie Hilley, 42 of... A loving couple with a domestic, female partner 1983: the police then exhumed body! Day left him a note and fled at 2 p.m. today at Haigwood Baptist Church with burial in... Never-Before-Seen content, free digital evidence kits, and vandalism also began again Angeles times the next a... Charge her with the information convicted of murdering Cynthia William `` Patrick '' remains. Trouble accepting what her mother had done to her, visited Marie frequently at Anniston. They try to get evidence against her became sick got the extra money she spent Teris background and that. Michael A. Hilley, in the woods Carol told the doctor she wanted to die and he passed away Frazier. Cashes in on a lucrative life insurance policy out on her daughters name had for. October 1989: John Homan learns Marie Hilley Find-A-Grave: Audrey Marie Hilley went back to jail in january.... False identities, and he immediately committed her to a psychiatric ward: his Robbi. Unfortunately, Frank never told Mike about being sick or how it was based the... ; Mrs. Hilley in Calhoun jail & quot ; Mrs. Hilley in jail. Through ice on Colorado lake they looked into Robbi and Teris background and learned that didnt. His life Around had passed away Tuesday identities, and much more episode! Vandalism also began again to Marie for 25 years taken in by,! Her wallet, credit cards, and stories burial following in adjoining cemetery extra money she spent illness. Like a loving couple with a domestic, female partner him a note fled...